9 replies to this topic

[Alzingery]

Are there true LOTR fans here? I really hope so, if yes what do you think of the new coming second movie of The Hobbit?Have you read any of Tolkien's books - Silmarilion and The Children of Hurin for example?

[Fico94]

well I read Hobbit and LOTR, unfortunately I didn't read Silmarilion and the children of hurin. I realy like LOTR trilogy, specially extended editions. I think it's mistake to shot three movies when there is only one book (Hobbit).

[imPurified]

The first Hobbit was amazing, can't wait for the second!

I read "The Hobbit" a few years back and it was great, really got me into reading.

[Duje Junakovic]

I have read Silmarilion and it is very hard to read like a rest of tolkien books but i liked it.

Edited by Duje Junakovic, 30 August 2013 - 10:31 PM.

[invaluable]

[Geondor]

i love lotr and the hobbit, they are the best books/movies ( i read them all )

[eyad.sai]

it was good movie  and  they added intersting  none orginal part in it. in general   the hobbit movies seems more lighter than  the lotir trilogy 

[Absinthium]

i've never read Silmarilion and The Children of Hurin because i didnt have the opportunity but read all the others and saw the movies and just loved it ^^

[Sagasa]

I loved the LOTR trilogy. I was a bit iffy about the Hobbit at first, but then the trailer showed Manly Dwarf Singing, and I just had to go and see it.

[plasticola]

Silmarilion is a very boring book of the series